
What would you do if you found out you were having surprise twins with someone you had known for only a few months?
In this episode of the Twiniversity Podcast, Natalie chats with Sayra Yepez about her surprise twin pregnancy with a man she just met.
Long story short, Sayra was an architect who left New York for California to start fresh. She walked into a bar one day, met the owner, and was pregnant by December.
At the first appointment, after she and her partner had spent the drive joking about twins, the nurse looked at the scan and told them there were two!
Fast forward, and Sayra’s twin girls are two and a half now. Inside this conversation, Sayra is completely honest about her surprise journey into twin parenthood, including:
- Conversations with people who loved her and were scared for her
- A relationship that had to evolve ten years in a week
- Postpartum depression so severe she didn’t even want to hold her babies
Keep reading for the biggest takeaways or watch the episode here.
Takeaway 1: Sometimes the universe answers a joke
Sayra and her partner met in August. Just four months later, she found out she was pregnant. They had already had the conversation about wanting kids, so the pregnancy itself didn’t feel like a crisis.
And on the way to the first appointment, she and her partner were laughing about the idea of twins, purely because it sounded absurd. Then the appointment unfolded, and they found themselves living the reality of that joke: the nurse said the scan showed two babies.
Sayra’s first response was to ask how much he had paid her to say it. The laughing turned into crying, and the crying turned into planning.
Takeaway 2: The fine print of “you can’t get pregnant on birth control”
This was Sayra’s first pregnancy after more than a decade in a previous relationship without a single scare, and she was on birth control.
But the reality is that most forms of birth control are not 100% effective. In fact, research shows that each year, pregnancy rates among women taking oral contraception is between 4 – 7%.
If you are counting on the odds, know what the odds actually cover.

Takeaway 3: Time isn’t the same thing as knowing someone
Sayra shares her thoughts on a common belief: the length of a relationship tells you very little about the relationship. She spent eleven years with someone and would not say she knew him all that well.
With her current partner, the very first conversations were the foundational one: do you want children, how many, who do you grab in a burning building? These are the questions most couples circle for years, but they talked until 5am in the morning getting to know these deep insights about each other. Of course, Sayra admits that she doesn’t claim to know everything about him. But she knows who he is fundamentally, and learning the rest is the fun part.
Takeaway 4: Telling the people who love you is its own kind of labor
The hard conversations Sayra had were not with strangers. They were with:
- Her roommate who was a college best friend, practically a brother, and who had been cheering on her wild-girl era
- Her sister in New York, who still checks in and asks if she is okay
- Family that had always cast her as the black sheep and was, ironically, mostly relieved someone had finally settled her down
One friend even told her flatly that it was a bad idea and that she was out of her mind. She cried and turned off the internet. Nat’s advice for that stretch of twin pregnancy: you already have too many voices coming at you, and you get to choose which ones you let in.

Need some twin parent friends? Get the support you need with a Twiniversity Membership. Benefits include a monthly twin parent club meeting on Zoom, access to a private Facebook group just for twin parents, and a video library of twin parenting lessons. Visit Twiniversity.com/membership to join today!
Takeaway 5: Sometimes, everything moves at once
For Sayra, that early stage was the logistics chapter, and it felt relentless. The lease had to be broken early. The roommate had to find a new place. Her partner had just moved into a fifth-floor walkup with a permanently broken elevator.
Sayra handled management, got the security deposit back, and they found a two-bedroom near his bar so his older kids would have a room when they stayed over. He bought a Volkswagen Atlas. In a matter of months, a new relationship transformed into a whole household.
Sayra was stressed about telling her partner’s older children, but the older girl slid straight into the big-sister role. Nat points out the timing seemed to work in their favor. At seven or eight, kids can get territorial, but teenagers mostly want to be left alone, and bonus babies are a fine distraction!

Takeaway 6: Her postpartum depression was severe, and she’s still working through it
While Sayra had a beautiful pregnancy, her postpartum days were brutal. She has exactly one photo from after the delivery, taken by her sister, and she did not want to meet her babies.
She didn’t want to hold them or be near them. She told her sister they had to leave. She felt like she wasn’t qualified for this and that it was all too much.
Two and a half years later, she describes herself as still pulling out of it. Nat, who has written about her own version of this, is direct: with twins, the landing is often a crash landing, hormonally and physically. And the guilt that follows those feelings is its own weight.
If any of this sounds like your postpartum experience, know that it is common, it is treatable, and you should absolutely tell your doctor or midwife the unedited version rather than the version that sounds acceptable. Help is available for you.

Takeaway 7: When everyone else’s twin story sounds happy and yours does not
Sayra names something people rarely say out loud: when you are in postpartum depression and you hear a glowing twin story, you do not feel encouraged, you feel worse.
Everyone around you is saying look how healthy they are, how could you not be happy. But your brain does not take pre-orders on positive thoughts.
Nat admits that she has sat across from beaming parents and wondered whether they were telling her the truth, or how many hands they had helping. She is careful not to yuck anyone’s yum. But if the happy version is not your version, you are not the weirdo, and you are not doing it wrong.
Takeaway 8: Regardless of the relationship, it’s hard to prepare for postpartum with twins
Nat shares that even twenty-five years together with your partner can’t fully prepare anyone for postpartum with multiples. It is a couples-therapy crash course either way.
Sayra gives her partner real credit: he saw that she was not herself, he named it, he was receptive. At the same time, he was also exhausted and working more than full time at the bar while she worked full time as an architect and did his books, PR, and design work on the side.

Around three months in, he told her this was nothing like his first two kids. Meanwhile, the actual village showed up in the form of a pregnant friend who moved in for a year and helped with the girls while going through her own pregnancy. Watching her friend’s pregnancy is also what made Sayra’s own memories come back, she had blocked out how tired those first months really were.
If you’re reading this while expecting twins, this isn’t meant to scare you but rather help you be gracious with yourself and your parenting partner.
Do your best to prepare for your twins (like attending Delivery Day Boot Camp or Caring for You & Two), and also realize that much of it you will have to learn as it comes.
Want to read more Twiniversity Podcast episodes or articles related to having surprise twins? Check these out too:
- I Got Pregnant With Twins While Using Protection
- Did You Find Out It Was Twins at a Later Ultrasound?
- Top Twiniversity Podcast Episodes






